French-door refrigerator, counter-depth, 25 cu ft illustration
French-door refrigerator, counter-depth, 25 cu ft
โณ LIFETIME REPAIR COST โ€” Maytag MFF2558FEZ
Expected lifespan10โ€“15 years
Repairs over its life2โ€“4 typical
Lifetime repair spend$650โ€“$1,250
Averages out to~$75/year

Common problems & typical repair costs

ProblemLikely causeTypical fixOEM part #Typical cost
Refrigerator warming, freezer fine Evaporator fan or coil icing Replace fan; address the defrost cause โ€” $205โ€“$410
Ice maker stops or produces hollow cubes Inlet valve or ice maker module Replace valve or maker WPW10312696 $185โ€“$405
Puddles inside and ice on the freezer floor Defrost drain clogged Clear drain, fit heater clip โ€” $125โ€“$260
Clicking and slowly warming Start relay or compressor Swap-test the start device first W11092533replaces W10798748 $150โ€“$900
Condensation around the door opening Gasket deformed or hinge sag Replace gasket; adjust hinge โ€” $155โ€“$360

Costs are national averages for professional repair (parts + labor). See the linked cost guides below for full breakdowns.

โš™๏ธ About these part numbers. These are the OEM part numbers for the Maytag MFF2558FEZ at the time of writing. Manufacturers supersede part numbers over time, and some parts split by serial-number range โ€” the same model built two years apart can take a different pump. Always check the number against the full model and serial number on your machineโ€™s tag before you order, and buy from a supplier who accepts returns on the wrong part. Not sure? A local appliance repair pro will confirm the right part in a two-minute phone call โ€” and often has it on the van.

Error codes

CodeWhat it means
Diagnostic mode Control panel sequence enters service mode
PO Power outage indicator โ€” press to clear
Sabbath icon Sabbath mode active, often mistaken for a fault

Tech notes

The compressor carries a ten-year limited parts warranty on this generation. On any sealed-system diagnosis, pull the model and serial and check coverage โ€” the part may be free even where labour is not.

Sources

Where the safety, regulatory and warranty claims on this page come from. Repair costs are our own figures based on Arizona market rates and OEM parts pricing.

Cost guides for this machineโ€™s common repairs

DIY step-by-step instructions for this model

DONโ€™T WANT TO DIY IT?

Find a refrigerator repair pro near you.

Browse verified independent appliance repair companies by city โ€” ratings, hours, and phone numbers, no middleman.

โ™ป๏ธ NOT WORTH FIXING?

We'll buy your Maytag MFF2558FEZ โ€” or haul it away.

If the repair costs more than this machine is worth to you, we'll quote you on taking it. Cash offer if it still has value, free or paid scrap pickup if it doesn't. We'll tell you honestly which it is.

Quote My Refrigerator โ†’ Free ยท No obligation ยท Arizona only

More Maytag guides